Book review of The Good Soldier

by Paula Benitez (Editor) Ford Madox Ford (Author)

Ford Madox Ford's The Good Soldier, published in 1915, is a poignant exploration of love, betrayal, and the shattering illusions of pre-World War I society. This masterful novel follows two seemingly idyllic couples, their seemingly perfect lives unraveling through a series of devastating revelations. Told retrospectively and non-chronologically through the unreliable narration of John Dowell, the story unfolds as a fragmented tapestry of memories and half-truths. Ford's innovative use of flashbacks and an increasingly untrustworthy narrator keeps the reader guessing, building suspense as the true nature of the characters' relationships is gradually exposed. Loosely based on real-life events and Ford's own experiences, The Good Soldier remains a compelling and psychologically complex study of human relationships.

The Good Soldier
3.8 / 1,987 ratings

Review The Good Soldier

Oh my goodness, The Good Soldier! This book has been haunting my "to-read" list for ages – it popped up in every British Lit course recommendation, then kept reappearing on "Best of the 20th Century" lists. Finally, I dove in, and now I understand the hype. From that stunningly melancholic opening line – "This is the saddest story I have ever heard" – to the final, gut-wrenching revelation, the novel is a masterclass in storytelling.

I immediately drew parallels to The Great Gatsby, published a decade later. Both feature affluent circles, flouted marriage conventions, and a first-person narrator who initially undersells his own significance in the unfolding drama. John Dowell, our American protagonist, promises to tell the story of the "good soldier," Captain Edward Ashburnham, but quickly reveals himself to be far more entangled than he lets on. However, the similarities end there. Ford Madox Ford's characters are far more deeply self-deceived than self-made, a crucial distinction. The cultural clashes – American vs. European, Protestant vs. Catholic – add fascinating layers to the already complex narrative.

Dowell is a truly captivating, and frustrating, narrator. He attributes the non-chronological storytelling to the limitations of memory, claiming he's recounting events as they surface in his mind. But his hesitancy, his constant backtracking, feels as much a product of his own reluctance to confront uncomfortable truths. The more he reveals, the more we suspect his "innocence" and his claim of being a mere bystander. To say more would be to spoil the incredible journey of discovery.

The novel's structure is a thing of beauty. It brazenly defies traditional narrative expectations; it’s a fascinating experiment in modern literary art, informed by the burgeoning field of psychology and rebelling against the rigid social codes of the Edwardian era. The way the story unfolds is just as important as the story itself. There's an electric energy that propels you forward, despite the often depressing subject matter. It’s a page-turner in the truest sense. The human weaknesses explored are palpable, deeply affecting, yet never presented with sentimentality.

While the plot is compelling, it's the characters that truly stay with you. The seemingly perfect couples, Edward and Leonora, and John and Florence, unravel before your eyes, revealing layers of deceit, manipulation, and profound sadness. Their relationships, seemingly conventional on the surface, are anything but. Ford masterfully portrays the hypocrisy and hidden tensions simmering beneath the veneer of Edwardian society. I found myself constantly questioning my perceptions of each character as new information was revealed – a testament to Ford's skillful manipulation of the unreliable narrator trope.

Reading The Good Soldier is not merely consuming a story; it's participating in a literary experience. It challenges, provokes, and lingers long after the final page is turned. It’s short, but packs a tremendous emotional and intellectual punch. If you're looking for a novel that’s both intellectually stimulating and emotionally resonant, this is a definite must-read. I highly recommend it.

See more: Honest review of ALL QUIET ON THE WESTERN FRONT

Information

  • Dimensions: 6 x 0.75 x 9 inches
  • Language: English
  • Print length: 297
  • Publication date: 2024

Preview Book

The Good SoldierThe Good SoldierThe Good SoldierThe Good SoldierThe Good SoldierThe Good SoldierThe Good Soldier